[轉]福建公車撞人見死不救事件調查結果遭質疑

隨風一起流浪

2009年3月3日，福建羅源縣政府一輛公車交通肇事導致一死一傷，有媒體在采訪完傷者和目擊者後披露，車禍發生之後，車內的幾名幹部紛紛下車，卻沒有上前救人，而是選擇了離開。

公車肇事且見死不救，在當地引起了強烈的社會反響。隨後，羅源縣成立了調查組，並于3月9日通過媒體發布了調查結果。調查結果顯示，肇事車確系該縣政府公用車輛，事發時車上有5名乘員，均系從羅源縣鄉鎮和縣直單位抽調參與該縣碧裏鄉航道疏浚的工作組成員，其中3人爲副科級以上幹部，兩人爲一般幹部。

調查結果認定，事故發生後，駕駛員陳某等人立即報警，車上下來的5名乘員及司機一直在車旁等待交警和醫務人員，直到交警和120救護車趕到事故現場處理才離開。

鑒于群衆反映有關人員在事故現場等待期間不作爲，羅源縣委作出決定，對3名副科級以上幹部予以停職，並由縣紀委、監察部門對所有相關人員進行徹查。

然而，這樣的調查結果公布之後，在當地卻引發了更多的質疑。值得注意的是，在調查結果中，羅源縣沒有認定媒體報道表述的“發生車禍時車上多名幹部見死不救，徑直離去”這一說法。有羅源縣的群衆質疑，政府有避重就輕，希望讓這一事件大事化小、小事化了的嫌疑。

在事故現場路邊的一家商鋪，當天目擊事故全過程的林先生告訴中國青年報記者，事故發生時，他看到從面包車上下來了幾個人，但都沒有去救那兩個被撞的群衆，而是走掉了。“電動車被撞之後，騎車的人被撞飛了十多米遠，一動不動。坐在電動車後面的人也倒在了地上，隨後又爬了起來，跌跌撞撞地朝騎車的人走去，沒走兩步就癱倒在地上，最後是爬到騎車者身邊去的，並且又哭又喊，沒有人上前給予幫助。”

在羅源縣醫院住院部，記者見到了正在接受治療的傷者羅小鳳。她告訴記者，3月3日那天，她和工友葉菊梅到縣城逛街，中午時分，由葉菊梅騎電動車載著她回家吃午飯。在一個路口，准備通過馬路時，不幸就發生了。

羅小鳳說，在她清醒之後，救援人員還未到現場，她並沒有看到有從車上下來的幹部在場，“爲什麽他們不來扶我們一把，或者送我們上醫院？”

羅小鳳告訴記者，事故發生後，她所在的位置離死者葉菊梅約有7~8米，離肇事車不到10米，而肇事車離葉菊梅也只有幾米遠，三者位置呈三角形。周邊的情況她看得很清楚，當時她的頭部和手腳都在流血，她曾靠著護欄站起來大聲呼喊“救命”，終因體力不支跌倒，但還是爬向工友葉菊梅，試圖施救。

中國青年報記者在羅源縣采訪時了解到，交警部門趕到事故現場大約是在事故發生後十分鍾。交警部門已經對“3·3交通事故”作出認定，縣政府公車車速過快是主要原因。駕駛員在駕車途經沒有交通信號燈控制、也沒有交通警察指揮的交叉路口時，未減速慢行，應負事故主要責任；死者葉某騎電動車載人，並且進入機動車道行駛，應負事故的次要責任。

羅源縣縣委宣傳部的一名幹部向中國青年報記者表示，事故發生之後，車上的幹部第一時間打電話報了警，並且都下車待在車旁，並沒有離開。“之所以當時沒有上前實施救援，是因爲車上所有的人都被這一突如其來的變故弄得不知所措，亂了方寸。”這名幹部補充道，“事件發生之後，縣裏的主要領導找了這些幹部談話，他們的這個說法由此次談話而來。”

記者得知，事故發生在羅源縣城郊，當時路口的交通監控攝像頭記錄下了事故發生的整個過程。在記者的一再要求下，宣傳部的工作人員才試著跟交警方面聯系，並領著記者去交警大隊看錄像。

令記者感到不解的是，交警表示事故發生在3日中午12時38分，然而，給記者觀看的錄像卻是事故發生後第10分鍾和第11分鍾的片段。

記者從錄像中看到，機動車道內，羅小鳳正搖搖晃晃地站在葉菊梅旁邊打電話，沒有任何人上前給予幫助。肇事車輛已經沖倒護欄並駛上人行道。畫面上顯示車輛周邊無人，在離肇事車輛尾部幾米遠的公路護欄旁和馬路另一側的護欄旁有少量圍觀人員，因爲監控錄像分辨率不高，無法看清體貌特征。

記者向羅源縣交警大隊隊長李建國表示，希望能看到整個事故的全過程，由此來確定這些幹部下車後是否還留在現場。得到的答複是，要看前面的一段內容，需要經過審批，因爲屬于保密的範疇。

記者問，交通事故發生後的監控錄像爲何也屬于保密範圍？李建國回答：“有的鏡頭不能看，那麽慘的東西（畫面），必須經過上級批准才行。”

记者问，该如何走程序申請才能获准？李建国说，要先到县公安局申請，还要得到市公安局的批准才行。记者几经争取，依然无果。

公車肇事，幹部見死不救，這一事件讓輿論沸沸揚揚。有評論表示，作爲一個普通公民，互幫互諒、扶貧濟困、救死扶傷都是起碼的社會公德，但在一場交通事故面前，政府幹部卻扮演了不光彩的角色，讓人心寒。能指望這樣的幹部爲人民服務嗎？他們能履行好自己的職責嗎？

羅源縣的群衆表示，希望政府實事求是，不要袒護，要讓這一場對官員的道德問責起到應有的警示作用。

隨風一起流浪

這起事故處理的……

隨風一起流浪

這就是人情大于法治的結果！
事發現場的監控錄象不讓看，的確讓人起疑！

塵即冰封的愛

怎麽做幹部的
人民的公仆呀[em3][em10]

勿忘我

怎麽做的幹部啊
     就该撤了[em11][em11]

隨風一起流浪

一個縣才多大呀，官官相護是難免的！

eagle1r

The Escaped PrisonerMr Stapleton came to the Hall and met Sir Henry that same afternoon.The next morning he took us to the place where the evil Sir Hugo died.Then we had lunch at the House.Sir Henry clearly thought Miss Stapleton was very beautiful.His eyes followed her everywhere.He liked her very much,and I was sure that she felt the same about him.He spoke about her again and again as we walked home.After the first meeting,we met the Stapletons almost every day.

After a short time it was clear that Sir Henry had fallen deeply in love with the beautiful Miss Stapleton.At first I thought that Stapleton would be very pleased if his sister mar ried Sir Henry.However,I soon realized that he did not want their friendship to grow into love.He did everything he could to make sure that they were never alone.On one or two occa sions they did manage to meet alone,but Stapleton followed them and was not pleased to see them together.
wow power leveling
I soon met another neighbour of Sir Henry's.His name was Mr Frankland,and he lived about four miles to the south of the Hall.He was an old man with a red face and white hair.He had two hobbies.The first was arguing.He argued with everybody.The second hobby was studying the stars.For this he had a very big telescope.For several days he had been watching the moor through the telescope.He wanted to find Selden,the escaped murderer.Nobody had seen the prisoner for a fortnight,and we all thought that he had probably left the moor.

A few nights later I was woken by a noise at about two in the morning.I heard someone walking softly outside my door.I got up,opened the door and looked out.I saw Barrymore moving carefully and quietly away from me.I followed him,as quietly as I could.He went into one of the empty bedrooms and left the door open.I went quietly up to the door and looked in side.

Barrymore was standing at the window.He was holding a light in his hand and looking out onto the moor.He stood without moving for a few minutes and then he put out the light.

I went quickly back to my room.A few minutes later I heard Barrymore go softly by.

The next morning I told Sir Henry what I had seen.

'We must follow him and find out what he is doing,'said Sir Henry.'He won't hear us if we move carefully.',wedding dresses,

That night we sat in Sir Henry's room and waited.At about three o'clock in the morning we heard the sound of footsteps outside the bedroom.We looked out and saw Barrymore.We followed him as quietly as we could.He went into the same room as before.We reached the door and looked in.There was Barrymore,with the light in his hand,looking out across the moor,exactly as I had seen him on the night before.

Sir Henry walked into the room and said:'What are you do ing here,Barrymore?'

Barrymore turned round quickly,surprise and horror on his face.

'Nothing,Sir,'he said.The shadows on the wall from his light were jumping up and down as his hand shook.'It was the window,sir.I go round at night to see that they are closed,and this one wasn't shut.'

'Come now,Barrymore,'said Sir Henry.'No lies.What were you doing with that light?You were holding it up to the window.'
wedding dresses,
I suddenly had an idea.'I think he was sending a message,' I said.'Let's see if there's an answer from someone on the moor.'

I held the light up to the window,and looked out into the darkness.Suddenly a light answered from the moor.

'There it is,'I cried.I waved my light backwards and for wards across the window.The light on the moor answered by moving in the same way.

'Now,Barrymore,who is your friend on the moor?What's going on?'

'That's my business,'said Barrymore,'I won't tell you.'

'Are you making some criminal plan against me?'Sir Henry said.
wow gold
'No,it's nothing against you,sir,'said a voice behind us.It was Mrs Barrymore.She had followed us and was standing at the door.'He's doing it for me.My unhappy brother is cold and hungry on the moor.We cannot let him die.Our light is to tell him that food is ready for him.His light shows us where to take it.'

'Then your brother is…'began Sir Henry.

'The escaped prisoner,sir.Selden,the murderer.He is my younger brother.He has done evil things,but to me he is still the little boy I loved and cared for.I had to help him.Every thing my husband has done has been for me.Please don't take his job from him.It's not his fault.'

Sir Henry turned to Barrymore and said:
wow power leveling,
'I cannot blame you for helping your wife.Go to bed,and we'll talk about this in the morning.'

The Barrymores left us.

'The murderer is waiting out there by that light,' said Sir Henry.'He's a danger to everyone.I'm going to catch him.If you want to come with me,Watson,fetch your revolver and let's go.'

We left the Hall immediately.

'We must surprise him and catch him.'said Sir Henry.'He's a dangerous man.Now,Watson,what would Holmes say about this?Do you remember what the old papers said? They said the Devil does his work when the world is dark.'

The Escaped Prisoner

曉蝶莊夢

  这样的事情  有多远 躲多远  记得有一个搀扶老人的事件啊  倒霉的还是好心人